While Cas wanted me to add my two cents to the wine review theme, I’m thinking that my opinion on the subject probably isn’t worth most people’s time to read. Thus, I’ll go with a subject I know something about, cheap Scotch Whisky.
First, you should note that, where Scotch is concerned, “whisky” is spelled correctly. The American version, such as Jack Daniels, is whiskey, with an “e,” and, even though they’re made from the same basic ingredients, there is a difference which you’ll just have to taste for yourself because I don’t have the words to explain it properly.
Second, when one talks cheap Scotch it means a blended product. If you read the Scotch labels at your local liquor store, you’ll find that some say “blended” and some say “single malt.” Blended means that batches from several breweries have been mixed together to maintain a consistent flavor for the product. Single malt means that the bottle contains only the product from a single brewery from a single batch, which means it’s unique and nothing will ever be bottled that is exactly the same again. From a taste perspective that may be good or bad, but the limitation on supply means the price is high, so single malts almost never fall into the cheap category, so for today’s post I’ll stick to blended varieties. Also, as to the actual taste of these beverages, much like the taste of wines, I could write a book and you could waste the time needed to read it and still not know what they taste like. With that in mind, I’m just shooting at giving you my general impressions and, hopefully, a little bit of guidance as to what is available for you to try.
And, after flipping a coin, I’ll approach this starting with the top end products. Oh, note this just includes stuff I’ve tasted sufficiently to form an opinion of.

Chivas Regal, the king of blended Scotch. It’s really good and, even though it can be more expensive than some single malts, this is the stuff to serve at parties if you want to impress your guests. The name, by the way, is well enough known that said guests don’t even need to know squat about the taste of good Scotch to be impressed, even if that taste is really quite nice. If you can afford it, it’s hard to go wrong with this one.

Johnnie Walker Black Label, is a close second to the king of Scotch title. In some areas it’s considered to hold the crown, and I can’t argue against that opinion. It’s also expensive and very good.

Cutty Sark, in my opinion, your best value for really good blended Scotch. Let me just say that, being the penny pincher I am, when I hit the lottery and become fabulously wealthy, this is what I’ll be drinking.

Dewar’s White Label, to my taste not quite as good as Cutty Sark, and the name’s not as interesting either. Still, it’s tasty, and if you only hit 5 out of 6 numbers, go for it.

Teacher’s Highland Cream. Good stuff. It’s better than what I usually drink, but you can find it on sale at times, and I recommend snatching up a bottle or three when this happens.

100 Pipers. Worth buying on sale just for the name. It’s good, but not good enough for the regular price. Still, it’s good.

Inverhouse. In my opinion this is the best buy for you money if you consume more than a little blended Scotch. It has good consistent quality and flavor from year to year, and you will find it difficult to match it on an alcohol per dollar basis. It’s nice to drink and provides a reasonably cheap buzz, perfect.

Highland Mist. Not quite as tasty as Inverhouse, to me at least, but still worth drinking. Plus it’s a bit less expensive. It hasn’t been available around here long enough for me to know how the quality and taste will vary over the years.

Lauder’s. Crap. It’s generally the cheapest Scotch on the market, and there’s a reason; it makes your pee stink. Truly, the flavor isn’t that much worse than the two above, but it really does make your pee stink. Like asparagus does, but worse. Really, four or seven shots of this stuff will make you hold your nose when your urinate the next day. I have no idea what they put in it to achieve this effect, but it can’t be good for you.
Enjoy,
the Grit
My husband loves Scotch and will only drink Chivas Regal…
I don’t think I have ever tried scotch.. I believe Chivas is what my grandfather drinks….
If I do try scotch…I’ll be sure to avoid the Lauders crap! LOL!
Hi C,
Your husband is a wise man with great good taste.
Hi Cas,
Well, Lauders is good if you want to play a trick on your doctor. Be forewarned, Scotch is an acquired taste.
the Grit
Well, I’m willing to try anything once…..Is it anything like whisky? I like Crown Royal.
Hi Cas,
It’s almost exactly like Crown Royal, which is a Scotch style whisky made in Canada. It can’t be Scotch, by the way, unless it’s made in Scotland, and that’s why I didn’t include Crown in the review. Oh, and I’ll do a post on single malts as soon as I save up enough money to do the research
the Grit
I think I am going to enjoy our little beverage reviews
Hi Cas,
It’ll be even more fun after we take this blog private, since then beverage, and food, purchases for review purposes, will be deductible as business expenses
God bless America!
the Grit
You are going to make the blog private?? I want to still be able to read it, can I? I got really drunk on Crown once and I can’t stand the smell of it now. Well it has been years, I could try it again. It was so smooth that is how I got so sick.
Hi C,
Private as in private hosting so we can be evil capitalists and make money advertising things like Crown Royal
And that brew is smooth!
Fortunately, my big experience with getting really sick from drinking was with a cheap brand of flavored vodka (cherry,) the smell of which also continues to turn my stomach, but it’s no big loss.
the Grit
MUAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA!!
Sorry, Lauder’s Scotch is not the best whiskey I have ever drunk, but it’s not the worst, either. I just tried it for the first time(straight-neat), and I really do like it! I mean, for the price, this is awesome stuff! I have tasted alot worse, which cost 3 times this amount. So, it all boils down to our personal taste, because some people love oysters, and some people puke at the sight of them. So, if you don’t like Lauder’s, then that is your tastebuds talking, not mine. Everyone is different. So, kind folks, don’t trust someone else’s tastebuds, trust your own. Try it, then judge it for yourself. Personally, I love Lauder’s Scotch!
Hi Jim,
Dude! I wasn’t bad mouthing Lauder’s flavor, only the effect it has on my bodily functions. So chill; I readily admit, insist even, that all things involving taste are individually subjective. Heck, I’ve screamed more that once at the TV when some idiot judge on Iron Chef says, “It doesn’t have enough salt.” And what I scream, sort of, is, “You fucking idiot! That’s why there’s a salt shaker on the damn table! Did your Imperial Majesty ever bother to consider that some of the common people don’t have Your salt addiction!”
Thus, I’d say that any Scotch is better than no Scotch.
the Grit
For the $35 a fifth Chivas Regal will cost me at my local liquor store I would much rather pay an extra $5 for The Glenlivet 12 year. The taste of a quality, 12 year single malt will blow a blended scotch out of the water any day and at $40 that can’t be beat.
Hi wmp35,
While I agree with you based on my personal tastes, for parties CR is more likely to please a higher percentage of guests and should be served. Of course, this in no way implies that you can’t keep a bottle of single malt out as well, or hidden in a cabinet
the Grit
Excellent Scotch review. I suggest that you try Grants, Bells & Famous Grouse. Three cheapish blends with a decent taste.
Hi John,
Thanks. I have tried Famous Grouse but it was long enough ago that I don’t remember the taste all that well. I’ve never seen the other two. So much Scotch, so little time.
the Grit
I enjoy Grant’s Family Reserve for a decent, low cost blended whisky. The flavor, smell and rich color suits me just fine.
Hi Ron,
Another brew that isn’t available here. If I ever chance across a bottle of it however, I will sample it.
the Grit
Of your list, the best buy is Teacher’s Highland Cream. Better than many entry level single malts. Nice post!
Speaking of Teacher’s Highland Cream, I not only like the scotch, but, I love the name. With a name like that, it’s just got to be good!
Dude, have you tried Clan MacGregor? Its a really nice smooth scotch for those that do not like really bland scotch. Nice flavors ranging from flowery, to cherry and wood. I’m no expert, though.
Ron, Grant’s Family Reserve is the one of the cheapest quality blended scotches available on the market. Try Teacher’s Highland Cream or Johnnie Walker Black. A world of difference buddy!
Grant’s is by far the best value blended scotch available. The Family Reserve draws from the Glenfiddich and Balvenie distilleries (among others), and so starts from the finest single malts around. It is on the sweeter side.
And, Lauders isn’t bad, but it’s also not that great.
Ian, just because the Family Reserve is made up of two great single malts (Balvenie & Glenfiddich) doesn’t automatically make it the best blend.
Famous Grouse is a blend whose chief components are Highland Park and Macallan, two single malts more highly regarded than Balvenie and Glenfiddich.
Ultimately, it is a matter of personal taste, but all I am saying is that it is wise to try a wide variety of blends. You might suprise yourself.
Cheers!
Jason